Introduction
Under California law, stalking is not a gray area. Penal Code § 646.9 makes it a crime to repeatedly follow or harass someone when the purpose is to scare them or make them fear for their safety. It doesn’t matter whether the conduct feels “persistent” or “misunderstood” to the person doing it—what matters is the fear it creates.
The statute is direct. Stalking laws in California consider actions that are intentional, persistent, and go beyond the bounds of intimidation to be stalking. There must be a credible threat. Something serious enough that an ordinary person would reasonably feel unsafe.
This is not a minor offense. It may be prosecuted as a felony or a misdemeanor depending on the circumstances. A conviction can lead to jail or prison time, fines, & long-term consequences.
The law stops calling it harassment at the point where unwanted attention becomes fear. It becomes a criminal act.
Examples
- Telling a coworker that “we will someday be together, whether we like it or not” over the phone each night without asking permission
- Sending a note that reads, “You’re next,” along with dead flowers to an ex-friend each week.
- Every other day, a note stating, “Take down the fencing or else,” is sent to the neighbor.
Defenses
In a stalking case, defense attorneys may raise a variety of legal defenses. Among them are demonstrating that:
- There was no intention to instill fear,
- The putative victim is fabricating the narrative,
- The threat was implausible, or
- You were engaging in a legal activity.
Penalties
In California, stalking is a “wobbler.” That’s legal slang for a crime that can swing either way depending on how much the prosecutor wants to throw the book at you.
1. The Criminal Hit
Misdemeanors: You’re looking at up to a year in county jail or a period of probation.
Felonies: This is the heavy hitter. You face up to five years in state prison.
2. Beyond the Jail Cell
The judge isn’t the only one you have to worry about. A conviction starts a chain reaction of other headaches:
-
- Civil Suits: The victim can sue you for money in civil court.
- Firearms: Say goodbye to your gun rights.
- Immigration: If you aren’t a citizen, this is a “deportable” offense.
The Clean-Up: There is one exit ramp: Expungement. You can ask to have the conviction removed from your record if you successfully complete your jail sentence and complete each day of your probation without making a mistake.
Must Read: Background Check Laws in California: Regulations Employers Must Follow
1. Stalking: What actually counts?
California doesn’t lock people up just for being “weird.” To nail you for stalking under Penal Code 646.9, the DA has to prove you weren’t just a nuisance—you were a predator.
Here is the reality of how they get a conviction:
- The Pattern: You didn’t just show up once. You followed them repeatedly or harassed them on purpose. The Stalking laws in California look for “malice.” It means you were actively trying to screw with their peace of mind.
- The Fear: You made a “credible threat.” Your goal was to make that person fear for their life. You’re in danger if an average person is afraid of you.
A. The “Safe Zones”
You can exercise your rights.
- Protesting: Carrying a sign or picketing legally.
- Talking: Exercising free speech, even if people hate what you’re saying.
- Meeting: Participating in a lawful assembly or rally.
The Reality Check: The Constitution protects your right to be a loudmouth at a protest. It does not protect your right to follow someone to their front door or threaten their kids. The moment it becomes about personal safety instead of public speech, the handcuffs come out.
B. Willfully, Maliciously, & Repeatedly
For the meaning of this code section, an act is committed knowingly if it is done voluntarily or intentionally.
When you purposefully commit a crime or act with the illegal intent to upset, irritate, or harm another person, you are doing so maliciously.
Repeatedly refers to more than once.
C. Harassment
Harassment is defined as intentionally and knowingly acting in a way that gravely irritates, scares, torments, or frightens.
Additionally, the behavior must have no justification.
A “course of conduct” is defined as two or more actions taken over a brief period of time with a consistent goal.
D. Credible Threat
A “credible threat” is defined by this statute as one that:
- Makes the subject of the threat legitimately fearful for their safety (or the protection of their closest relatives, pet, service animal, psychological assistance pet, or horse), and
- One that you seem capable of carrying out.
One could make a plausible threat verbally, in writing, or digitally.
Additionally, a pattern of behavior or a mix of behavior and comments may imply it.
E. Reasonable Fear
The court will determine whether you meant to put “the victim” in reasonable fear by examining the situation’s specifics & circumstances.
The “real threats” are those that are uttered with the intention of instilling fear.
The following are not real threats:
- Exaggerated political declarations,
- Humorous remarks, or
- Speech is protected by the Constitution.
F. Immediate Family
This code part defines “immediate family” as:
- Child, parent, or spouse,
- Grandchild, grandparents, siblings connected by marriage or blood, and
- Anyone who frequently resides in the home.
2. Defenses
A strong legal defense will help you avoid being accused of stalking. Reducing or dismissing a charge is possible with a strong defense.
There are three typical defenses for PC 646.9 accusations:
- No real danger
- No intention to incite fear, or
- Engage in activities protected by the Constitution
A. There Wasn’t a Real Danger
Remember that this code clause only holds you accountable if you make a “credible threat” to a claimed victim. Your defense is to demonstrate that the threat is neither believable nor serious. For instance, you might have made a lighthearted threat to someone.
B. There was no intention to instill fear
This is comparable to the previous defense. You might argue that you did not mean for someone to be terrified. This is despite the fact that you may have threatened them. For instance, you might have repeatedly threatened to tickle someone.
C. Your Behavior Was Protected by the Constitution
Remember that if you were participating in an officially recognized activity (like peacefully protesting), you are not guilty of stalking under this provision. It is always an excellent defense to demonstrate that you committed such an act.
3. Penalties
You will be subject to two main penalties if you commit the crime of stalking.
- Criminal penalties,
- Civil penalties
A. Criminal penalties
Misdemeanor offense:
- Misdemeanor (basic) probation,
- A maximum penalty of $1,000, and/or
- A year in the county jail
Felony offense:
- Felony (or official) probation,
- A fine of as much as $1,000, or
- Up to five years of imprisonment in state prison
Stalking will perpetually be prosecuted as a felony in particular situations.
- The stalking violated a protection order granted by the court, or
- You had previously been found guilty of stalking (even though the claimed victim in the latest instance is not the same individual you previously harassed).
B. Civil Penalties
The claimed stalking victim may file a civil lawsuit against you for stalking-related damages in addition to facing criminal sanctions.
In a civil legal case, a victim of stalking must demonstrate three elements in order to be awarded damages. These are:
- You followed, alarmed, or harassed the “victim” through a pattern of behavior (they require independent evidence, in addition to their testimony, to demonstrate this),
- The victim genuinely feared for their own safety or the security of a close relative, and
- You refused to cease your harassing conduct after the victim requested you to, or
- Your actions were in violation of a restraining order.
The accused victim may be entitled to both if they are able to demonstrate these:
- Punitive damages, and
- Compensatory damages
4. Immigration Repercussions
If you aren’t a U.S. citizen, a stalking conviction is a straight-up immigration nightmare.
The feds don’t just care about jail time; they care about whether your crime makes you “deportable” or “inadmissible.” If you hit either of those labels, you’re looking at losing your green card or getting kicked out of the country for good.
A. The “Danger” Zones
U.S. immigration law has a hit list of crimes that can trigger deportation.
- Aggravated Felonies: There is a big risk if your stalking accusation is elevated to a felony. It can be under the “unpardonable” category.
- Moral turpitude crimes: Crimes proving a “bad character.”
- Domestic Violence: You’re in trouble if the victim is an ex or a family member.
B. The Felony Trap: “Aggravated Felony” label is a big risk. It’s a massive red flag if a judge decides your stalking case was serious enough to be a felony. Your chances of staying in the U.S. drop to almost zero once that happens.
C. The Harsh Reality: You could finish your sentence, pay every dime you owe the state of California, and still get picked up by ICE the moment you walk out of jail.
5. Expungements
Getting a stalking conviction off your record is possible. You have to earn it. In California, this is called an expungement (under Penal Code 1203.4).
Think of it as a “legal reset.” Once a judge grants it, you are officially released from almost every penalty the conviction slapped on you. The massive upside? You need not disclose it to your employer.
An expungement for a conviction under felony/misdemeanor is possible.
- You completed probation successfully, and
- Are not serving a term for a crime, on probation for another, or facing criminal charges.
This means that you can start attempting to have the felony erased once you completed your probation (in the event that it was enforced) or served a jail sentence (if appropriate).
6. Gun Rights
If you get hit with a felony stalking conviction in California, you can kiss your gun rights goodbye.
The Stalking laws in California are extremely strict about who is allowed to own or even touch a firearm. There is a “blacklist” of people who are banned from possessing weapons, and if your stalking charge gets bumped up to a felony, you are on it.
A. The “No-Gun” List: California doesn’t just ban people for stalking; they ban a wide range of individuals to keep weapons out of “dangerous” hands:
- All Felons: It doesn’t matter what the crime was. You lose your rights if it’s a felony.
- Addicts: Anyone addicted to narcotics.
- Repeat Offenders: People with convictions (more than two) related to “brandishing a weapon.”
- Specific Misdemeanors: Some crimes carry a lifetime ban (domestic violence, etc.)
- Mental Health & Age: Those with certain mental illnesses or anyone under 21.
B. The Stalking Trap: Your gun rights are essentially in the hands of the prosecutor because stalking is a “wobbler.”
- You might keep your rights if they charge & convict you of a misdemeanor.
- You are prohibited from owning or buying a gun if the conviction is a felony.
A felony stalker is a high-risk individual. A conviction doesn’t just mean jail time—it means a permanent surrender of your Second Amendment rights.
7. Associated Offenses
Stalking cases don’t usually live in isolation. Other charges often follow once law enforcement starts looking closely. It’s because the same behavior can cross multiple legal lines at once.
Kidnapping is one of them. Stalking laws in California treat it very seriously for good reason. It isn’t about watching someone or making them uncomfortable. It’s about physical control. A person should not be forced or frightened into moving a significant distance. The law steps in. That physical movement is what separates kidnapping from stalking. Without it, the charge doesn’t stick.
Then there are harassing phone calls. Repeated calls. Obscene messages. Threats meant to unsettle or wear someone down. California makes that behavior a crime on its own. It can look a lot like stalking on the surface. The intent matters. Fear isn’t required. Once fear becomes the goal, the conduct starts drifting into stalking territory.
Criminal threats sit in a different space. This isn’t about patterns or persistence. It’s about the weight of the words themselves. One serious threat can be enough if it’s clear, specific, and believable. If the person on the receiving end reasonably fears for their safety—or their family’s safety—the law doesn’t need repetition. The damage is already done.
That’s why these charges often travel together. Stalking focuses on behavior over time. Criminal threats focus on the moment. Kidnapping focuses on physical control. Different angles, same reality. And once conduct crosses from uncomfortable into dangerous, the legal consequences escalate quickly.
8. Assistance for Victims
Take action if someone believes/knows they are being stalked. The must:
- Take steps before the harassing behavior gets out of control.
- Tell the stalker to cease the unwanted contact.
- Do not interact with the stalker after that.
- Report the stalking to relatives, close companions, & the employer.
- Call the police and file a report.
- Make an effort to preserve every piece of evidence of the stalking.
- Get in touch with a credible lawyer. They can be your real strength in fighting a case.
Responding to a Stalking Accusation
California does not treat stalking lightly. Once a charge is filed, the system assumes risk, not misunderstanding. That’s why waiting things out or trying to “explain it later” is usually a mistake.
This is the point where you need a defense lawyer who actually handles stalking cases. You don’t need general advice or Google searches. These cases turn on details: intent, context, and credibility. Miss those early, and they harden against you.
A good defense attorney can step in before damage becomes permanent. That might mean pushing for a lesser charge, cutting off exaggerated allegations, or stopping a weak case from going any further. Sometimes it’s about limiting exposure. Sometimes it’s about ending the case entirely.
Either way, the risk is real. Jail time, restraining orders, job fallout—those consequences don’t wait. The only smart move is to get someone in your corner early, before the story gets written without you.
Conclusion
Stalking laws in California draw a clear line between unwanted behavior and criminal conduct. Penal Code § 646.9 is not concerned with social awkwardness, persistence, or misunderstandings—it is concerned with fear. Once conduct becomes intentional, repeated, and aimed at making someone reasonably fear for their safety, the law treats it as a serious offense. The consequences are real and lasting. Jail or prison time, civil liability, firearm restrictions, immigration consequences, & long-term damage to one’s record.
The Stalking laws in California are not limitless, though. Prosecutors have to demonstrate repeated intent and a real threat. The statute does not apply to protected speech or lawful activity. It does not apply to behavior that does not pose a real threat. That balance is intentional. It protects victims without criminalizing everyday behavior.
Stalking cases turn on context and credibility. Understanding where lawful conduct ends and criminal exposure begins is critical. When fear becomes the outcome, California law is designed to intervene decisively.