Are employers required to pay for unauthorized overtime?

An employer can discipline an employee if he or she violates the employer’s policy of working overtime without the required authorization. An employer is required to pay an employee who works overtime regardless of whether the employee received permission to perform the work. An employer may reprimand, demote, or fire an employee for working unauthorized overtime hours.

By Brad Nakase, Attorney

Email  |  Call (888) 600-8654

Get Smarter: Search my blogs

Understanding and Managing Unapproved Extra Hours

If the employer knows that the employee worked overtime, whether it was authorized overtime or unauthorized overtime, the employer has to pay for it. If, however, the employer truly has no knowledge of the overtime work, the employer will not have to pay for the unauthorized overtime. Unapproved extra hours can create big problems for your small business. Higher expenses, lower employee happiness and efficiency, and higher staff turnover are just a few ways extra work can cause trouble. Workers putting in unapproved overtime can lead to money issues, safety problems, and even legal challenges. Business owners often face stress trying to balance paying for extra work and keeping their teams happy. Here’s a detailed guide on what unapproved overtime means, the rules around it, and how to stop it effectively.


What is Overtime and Unapproved Overtime?

In the workplace, overtime is any time worked beyond a usual 40-hour week. For hours worked past 40, employees must be paid an overtime rate that’s at least one-and-a-half times their normal pay. For instance, if you usually pay someone $20 an hour, you need to pay them at least $30 an hour for overtime. Overtime pay ensures workers are fairly compensated for working more than the standard hours.

Unapproved overtime is any extra time that isn’t approved by management in advance. It can be obvious (like asking workers to stay late to finish an inventory job) or small overtime. Small overtime is more common. It happens when someone shows up a little early or clocks out 10 to 15 minutes late. This can also be called stealing time. While the time may seem small, over weeks or months, it adds up to big costs for employers.

Examples of unapproved overtime include working during an unpaid break, answering messages and reading emails after clocking out, or staying late after hours to finish a task. These actions might seem harmless to the worker, but they can disrupt the employer’s planning and budget.


Why Overtime Rules Exist

Overtime rules exist to protect workers. Without these rules, employers might ask workers to put in long hours without fair pay. In the past, some businesses took advantage of workers, asking them to work many hours for very little money. Overtime laws ensure workers are treated fairly and paid for the extra time they spend at work. These laws also help employers create better schedules and keep their teams healthy and productive.

Overtime isn’t just about money—it’s also about fairness. Workers who put in more hours should be rewarded for their extra effort. These rules also prevent companies from overworking employees to save money.


When is a Worker Legally Entitled to Overtime?

Many employers simply do not allow unauthorized/unapproved overtime, and they outline this in the company handbook.  When employees work unauthorized overtime, the company has to pay overtime wages, which can quickly add up. But that’s not the only concern. Overtime rules are made to protect workers, ensuring they get fair pay for extra hours. Federal overtime laws say overtime must be paid to workers who are not exempt and who work over 40 hours in one week. Both hourly and salaried employees can be non-exempt, as long as they:

  • Earn less than $684 weekly or $35,568 each year.
  • Do jobs outside of exempt professions.

There’s no set limit in the law on how many overtime hours someone can work in a week. Whether it’s 45, 60, or 80 hours, you still have to pay overtime. Also, working on weekends, holidays, or rest days doesn’t automatically mean overtime pay. But if overtime happens during one of these times, the worker is still entitled to it.

California’s Overtime Pay Law

Employers are liable for paying unauthorized overtime, no matter the reason it was worked. Under California overtime law, the basic overtime laws say that a non-exempt worker who is 18 or older, or a 16- or 17-year-old who is not legally required to attend school and isn’t forbidden from the work, cannot work more than eight hours a day or 40 hours a week unless they are paid one-and-a-half times their usual pay for all hours over eight in a day and over 40 in a week.

An employer who requires or permits an employee to work overtime is generally required to pay the employee premium pay for such overtime work. Employees covered by the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) must receive overtime pay for hours worked in excess of 40 in a workweek of at least one and one-half times their regular rates of pay.

California also has unique overtime rules that go beyond federal laws. For example, employees working more than 12 hours in a single day must be paid double their regular pay rate for those hours. These rules ensure workers in California receive extra pay for longer shifts.


Examples of Jobs with Overtime

Some jobs are more likely to involve overtime than others. Workers in healthcare, retail, manufacturing, and delivery often face overtime situations. For example:

  • Healthcare Workers: Nurses and doctors might stay extra hours to help patients during emergencies.
  • Retail Workers: During busy seasons like holidays, retail employees might work overtime to keep shelves stocked and customers happy.
  • Delivery Drivers: With the rise of online shopping, delivery drivers often work overtime to meet tight deadlines.

Understanding how different industries handle overtime helps both employers and workers plan better schedules.


Do Employers Need to Pay for Unapproved Overtime?

The answer is yes. According to California law, overtime must be paid regardless of whether an employee gets advanced authorization to work overtime. Employees are almost always legally owed overtime pay, even if it wasn’t approved. According to §785.11 of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) regulations, “Work not asked for but allowed is still work time.” Also, §785.13 says, “In all such cases, it is the management’s job to take control and stop the work if they don’t want it done.”

California Labor Commissioner’s advice also says that “an employee cannot purposely stop the employer from knowing about unapproved overtime work and then later demand pay. The employer must have the chance to follow the law.” However, if the employer knows (or should know) that the worker was working from home, they must pay for the overtime.


Why It’s Important to Stop Unapproved Overtime

Unapproved overtime hurts employers in many ways. It takes up your time, costs you money, and lowers team morale—and that’s on a good day. Long periods of overtime work, especially without approval, can harm employees. They might feel worn out, leading to more stress. Over time, this can lower overall efficiency.

Safety problems can also happen. When workers take overtime without telling you, fewer safety measures are in place. If they’re tired or overworked and an accident happens, or someone’s safety is at risk, you could face serious issues.


Steps to Stop Unapproved Overtime

Stopping unapproved overtime takes planning. With the right rules, clear communication, helpful tools, and steady follow-through, unapproved overtime can be avoided.

  1. Clear Communication: Create and explain clear rules about overtime. Open conversations between workers and their managers can help identify possible overtime problems early.
  2. Use Technology: Modern tools like time-tracking software can warn when an employee is close to hitting their maximum hours, notifying both the worker and their supervisor.
  3. Set Overtime Limits: Talk to your team so employees are less likely to take unapproved or accidental overtime. Regularly discussing these limits helps build a culture where workers don’t feel pressured to work extra hours.
  4. Cross-Train Employees: Avoid relying too much on one group of employees for certain tasks. By teaching workers to handle different jobs, your team can adjust better and avoid overtime.
  5. Balance Workloads: Uneven tasks can make employees feel forced to take overtime. Spread out tasks fairly to ensure even workloads.
  6. Create Fair Rules for Overtime: Some employees might think management has favorites for overtime chances. A fair system discourages overtime “hogs” and ensures overtime hours are shared fairly.

Extra Tips for Employers

Employers should regularly review their overtime policies to make sure they follow the law. Training managers to spot and address overtime early can save time and money. For workers, asking questions about overtime policies can prevent misunderstandings. Both sides need to work together to avoid issues.


Enforcing Rules and Consequences

While employers must pay for unapproved overtime, they are allowed to discipline workers who break company rules. Employers who want to avoid paying for unapproved overtime can actively discourage extra hours by setting, sharing, and enforcing a clear rule.

For example, if an employer finds out a worker worked overtime without permission, they can and should discipline the worker, but they still must pay for the extra hours worked.


Conclusion

Unapproved overtime can strain both a company’s resources and its workers’ well-being. Every employer has a legal and moral duty to pay for all hours worked but can take steps to avoid unapproved overtime. With clear rules, regular communication, and modern tools, businesses can reduce the risks and costs of unapproved overtime while supporting a healthy and productive team.

Have a quick question? We answered nearly 2000 FAQs.

See all blogs: Business | Corporate | Employment Law

Most recent blogs:

Can Managers Receive Tips in California? No.

Can Managers Receive Tips in California? No. Under California law, a manager cannot take any part of a tip that's left for an employee. This means that you can't be forced to share your tips with the manager, supervisor, or owner of the business.  In California, when an employer or another supervisor or manager takes an employee's tips, it is considered a wage and hour violation.

Can Managers Take Tips In California?

No, in California, it is strictly prohibited for your manager to take tips that are intended for employees. California labor laws clearly state that tips are the sole property of the employees to whom they are given, and managers, supervisors, or employers cannot collect, share, or deduct any portion of these gratuities.

Lawyer Answers FAQ: California Lunch Break Law and Meal Break Law

Most California workers must receive the following breaks: An uninterrupted 30-minute unpaid meal break when working more than five hours in a day. As a general rule, and insofar as practicable, the rest break must be in the middle of each four-hour work period.

When did tips become taxable?

Tips became taxable in 1965 when legislation extending Social Security coverage to tips (for both taxation and the calculation of retirement benefits), required a tipped employee to report monthly all such tips received in one or more written statements furnished to his employer.
Is Job Abandonment Considered a Resignation in California

Is Job Abandonment Considered a Resignation in California?

Job abandonment in California is viewed as voluntary resignation when employees fail to notify their employer after extended absences. Employers should implement clear policies, address legitimate exceptions, and follow labor laws to manage job abandonment appropriately

California Lunch Break Law [2025]

This article answers common questions, such as "How many hours do you have to work to get a lunch break?" and "Can I work 6 hours without a lunch break in California?" Under California law, employees must be provided with no less than a thirty-minute lunch break when the work period is more than five hours. In California, an employer may not employ an employee for a work period of more than five hours per day without providing the employee with a lunch break.
Overtime - Understanding California’s laws and employee rights

Overtime: Understanding California’s laws and employee rights

California's overtime laws require non-exempt employees to receive extra pay for working over 8 hours a day or 40 hours a week. Employees must be compensated at 1.5 times their regular rate for hours beyond these limits and double pay for excessive hours on the 7th consecutive workday.

Why would someone ask for their personnel file?

Employees who believe they have been fired as a result of unlawful discrimination, retaliation, or harassment will often request their personnel file. Those files may contain information that helps you prove discrimination, harassment, or other civil rights violations.

Can You Refuse to Work If You Haven’t Been Paid?

Legally, you may have the right to refuse work if your employer hasn't paid you because it is constructive termination and wage theft by the employer. If your employer hasn't paid you, should should review your contract before not working.

What Happens If I Don’t Get Paid on Payday?

If you don't get paid on payday, contact an employment attorney immediately and ask for help getting the wages owed to you. Alternatively, if the regular payday for the last pay period an employee worked has passed and the employee has not been paid, contact the Department of Labor's Wage and Hour Division or the state labor department. 

How long can an employer not pay you?

Your employer must pay you on pay day if you did not resign or fired from your job. If you're fired from your job, you must be paid the same day. If you quit your job, you must be paid within 3 days. 

Do You Get Paid for Training? 

In California, employees are generally entitled to be paid for training as long as its job-related and mandated by the employer.

Is Unpaid Training Legal in California?

Yes, unpaid training is illegal in California. California employers must pay for mandatory training. Employees not paid for meetings or job training can sue for unpaid training.

Is It Illegal To Not Pay Overtime?

Yes, it is illegal for employer to not pay overtime. Overtime pay is 1.5 times an employee's regular rate of pay. Not all employees are eligible for overtime.
Is It Illegal to Work Seven Days a Week

Is It Illegal to Work Seven Days a Week?

Working seven days a week varies by state, with California laws addressing rest days and overtime pay rules. Employers must ensure compliance with labor laws to guarantee proper compensation and protect employee wellbeing.
How Many Hours per Week Is Considered Full Time

How Many Hours per Week Is Considered Full Time?

Find out what constitutes full-time employment, typical workweek lengths, and the benefits of full-time jobs, including health insurance and PTO. Learn how employers define full-time hours, overtime rules, and requirements for family leave under FMLA.

How To Report A Company Paying Employees Under The Table

If you are an employee being paid under the table, you can make a whistleblower report by contacting attorney Brad Nakase. Attorney Nakase does not charge an upfront fee and works on a contingency basis, collecting a percentage of the recovery. This ensures you can pursue your claim without financial barriers.

Contact our attorney.

Please tell us your story:

3 + 3 = ?