Choosing between an LLC and an S Corp impacts taxation, liability, and management structure. Business owners should evaluate growth potential, tax implications, and operational complexity before selecting the best option.
By Brad Nakase, Attorney
Email | Call (888) 600-8654
Have a quick question? I answered nearly 1500 FAQs.
A handbook to assist entrepreneurs choose the best business structure for their needs, including how to form an LLC or corporation.
Owners of businesses can set up their organizations in a variety of ways, depending on a number of factors, including the size of the company, its potential for expansion, management style, the owners’ preferred tax structure, and many more. A trained tax specialist, such as a bookkeeper or tax lawyer, should be consulted by anybody launching a firm to determine which business structure best suits their objectives. However, it is helpful to know some of the criteria that usually play a role in these decisions.
A lot of entrepreneurs are curious about the many kinds of business ownership and how to choose the best one for their company. The most frequent queries that prospective entrepreneurs have regarding the organization of a company in the US are listed below.
Five basic company structures are available for new businesses: LLCs (limited liability companies), partnerships, sole proprietorships, S corporations, and C corporations.
S corps and C corps are two of the most popular forms of commercial arrangements. While each form has pros and cons, and both of these companies have different taxes, there are also parallels. Understanding the differences between LLC vs S Corp can help entrepreneurs make informed decisions about their business structure.
Both the C & S corps:
Both C and S organizations have advantages and disadvantages, but which one best fits your needs will depend on the objectives and type of your company. The LLC vs S Corp debate is an essential consideration for small business owners evaluating their tax liabilities and operational flexibility.
A C corporation, S corporation, or LLC are not intrinsically “better”; rather, they just indicate how a business is taxed and which regulations it must follow to maintain IRS (Internal Revenue Service) compliance. The type, scale, and objectives of the company in question ultimately determine how one must incorporate.
S corps are typically sole proprietorships or smaller firms, while C corps are typically larger corporations, however, this isn’t always the situation. In fact, there is a lot of ambiguity in determining the best tax status for expanding small and mid-sized businesses, including LLC vs S Corp (a topic we’ll talk about later).
In general, a C Corp—so-called because it is included in IRS code subchapter “C”—is a separate legal organization that is held by its stockholders and has limitless expansion potential. Because C corporations are a corporate structure that permits indefinite expansion through the sale of shares (which attracts investors) and is perfect for large, retail-based firms, the majority of public companies and large businesses are established as C corporations.
One more characteristic that sets C corps apart is that they’re twice taxed. This implies that the business is taxed at the 21% federal corporation tax rate initially and that any earnings or dividends distributed to shareholders are subject to a second taxation as personal income. As we’ll see later, avoiding double taxation is actually one of the strongest arguments for filing as an S corp. This tax consideration is a major factor in the LLC vs S Corp decision-making process.
The majority of the various advantages of forming a C Corp are related to tax benefits and growth strategies. However, making a C Corp can be costly due to its complexity, which typically necessitates consulting with tax or legal experts to assist with federal and state filing obligations as well as papers like bylaws and the Certificate of Incorporation. The cost of labor and management also goes up, and a company’s complexity and cost increase with its size.
Benefits of a C Corp include:
Among the drawbacks of creating a C company are:
However, forming a C Corp can be the ideal option for business owners who want to build a firm with room to develop and plenty of investment options. In contrast, business owners looking for simpler tax structures often compare LLC vs S Corp to determine the best fit for their operations.
Establishing a C Corp requires a significant amount of upfront labor and a legally enforceable commitment to the organization’s objectives and performance, therefore it is not something that should be done lightly.
An owner of a business must do the following in order to create a C Corp:
All of these phases demand a lot of consideration and/or action. Forming a C corporation is a complex process that usually entails speaking with a tax lawyer and, after the business is operational, investing in software to guarantee that all tax returns are accurate. These and other factors make the process difficult. Alternatively, the simpler choice of forming an S Corporation could be preferred by many entrepreneurs.
An S Corp, as defined by Subchapter S under the IRC (Internal Revenue Code), is a business corporation that chooses to distribute taxable income, losses, credits, and deductions to its shareholders. They are well-liked primarily because S corps are attractive to sole proprietors and small enterprises due to their attractive tax benefits and liability safeguards for personal property.
Due to their status as “pass-through corporations,” S corps are exempt from federal taxes on their taxable income. Instead of averting double taxation, they “pass-through” straight to the individual tax returns of the company’s owners and its shareholders, as S corporations are exempt from paying federal taxes. Rather, they pay local and state income taxes of up to 13.3%, and S Corp proprietors may pay federal individual income taxes on their earnings and profits of between 10% and 39.6%.
S Corp owners can save a lot of money on their taxes by reporting corporate profits, losses, credits, and deductions on their individual tax returns. In fact, S Corp stockholders may deduct as much as 20 percent of their QBI (Qualified Business Income) as a result of the Tax Cuts & Jobs Act (2017), potentially lowering a person’s tax liability by 20–25%. Apart from lowering taxes, the S Corp format shields the owners’ private assets from lawsuits and debt collection efforts aimed at the S Corporation.
Operating an S company has a number of benefits, but it also has drawbacks.
The following are some benefits of forming an S Corp:
The following are the drawbacks of an S Corp:
Granted, an S corporation’s restrictions may deter potential investors and make raising money more challenging, but they may also draw in investors who desire a closer relationship with the company.
But not all kinds of companies can decide to become S corporations. For example, financial organizations, insurance businesses, and multinational corporations are not allowed to be S corporations. Additionally, S corporations are subject to more stringent compliance standards than other company organizations like limited liability partnerships (LLPs) or LLCs. Additionally, S Corp owners risk fines from the IRS when they fail to maintain accurate records or provide their staff wages that the IRS considers “fair.”
Even though it’s simpler to form an S Corp than a C Corp, there are still a few processes involved.
The following are the essential steps to create an S Corp:
Particularly for solo proprietors or small business owners, C or S corporations may appear excessively complicated in terms of corporate structures. It may be your preference to continue operating your small company as a sole proprietor, who retains all net profits and makes every business decision. But if you’re a contractor or freelancer and you don’t have a company structure in place, you can lose your personal assets if, for instance, a client sues you.
The most popular small company organization structure is the LLC (Limited Liability Company), which is an alternative if you want to safeguard your private possessions but are reluctant to create a C or S corp. Many entrepreneurs engage in the LLC vs S Corp discussion to determine which structure best suits their business needs.
In addition to safeguarding a business owner’s private wealth, LLCs are also advantageous due to their ease of formation.
The benefits of creating an LLC include:
The following are some drawbacks of creating an LLC:
Owners of LLCs can reduce their personal self-employment taxes by switching to a C Corp or S Corp tax classification while maintaining the LLC structure. Social Security taxes are 12.4% and Medicare taxes are 2.9% of the 15.3% self-employment tax. Additionally, the tax rate on the personal income of the LLC owner, which varies based on the person’s tax bracket, can range from 10 to 37%.
Consider an LLC owner who earns $125,000 as gross sales and incurs $10,000 as company expenses. Profits of $115,000 are realized by the LLC owner, which sounds wonderful. For the $115,000, the LLC owner must now pay personal income tax and self-employment tax at a rate of 15.3%, minus any deductions.
LLC owners may opt to submit taxes as S corporations and benefit from reduced personal tax rates, even if the majority of them will not choose to file as C corporations due to the substantial corporate tax rate on income of 21%. Although the LLC owner must follow certain IRS rules unique to S Corp status, new tax law changes could enable an LLC owner filing as an S Corp to benefit from the QBI (Qualified Business Income) deduction, which lets filers deduct up to 20% of their company’s profits from their taxes.
All business executives should ask themselves the questions listed above to decide which form of ownership is best for their company, regardless of the type of business they run. Selecting the right business structure is crucial and shouldn’t be done hastily. Examine your alternatives and select the option that best suits your company’s objectives after giving careful thought to the type of business you plan to launch and run. Whether choosing LLC vs S Corp, careful planning and professional guidance can help ensure long-term business success.
Have a quick question? We answered nearly 2000 FAQs.
See all blogs: Business | Corporate | Employment Law
Most recent blogs:
Contact our attorney.