Understanding Contingency Fee Arrangements
A contingency fee agreement is a payment structure where an attorney’s compensation is dependent upon winning a case or securing a settlement. If the case is unsuccessful, the client does not owe the attorney a fee for their services. These agreements are common in personal injury cases, employment disputes, medical malpractice claims, and other civil matters where monetary compensation is sought.
How Contingency Fees Are Calculated
In a contingency fee agreement, the attorney and client agree that the lawyer will receive a percentage of the final settlement or court award. The percentage is typically determined by several factors, including the complexity of the case, the stage at which it is resolved, and applicable state laws. Below are common contingency fee structures:
-
Standard Contingency Fee Percentages
- Contingency fees usually range from 33% to 45% of the recovered amount.
- Some cases, especially those with high potential recoveries exceed $1 million, may have lower percentages (e.g., 25%).
- In cases requiring significant legal work, such as medical malpractice or complex litigation, fees may be higher (e.g., 40% to 45%).
-
Sliding Scale Contingency Fees
Some agreements incorporate a tiered percentage structure where the attorney’s fee depends on the stage of the case:
- Pre-Lawsuit Settlement: If the case is resolved through negotiations before filing a lawsuit, the attorney might take 25% to 33% of the settlement.
- After Filing a Lawsuit: If the attorney has to litigate but settles before trial, the fee may increase to 35% to 40%.
- After Trial Begins: If the case goes to trial, the attorney may take 40% to 45% of the final judgment.
- Appeal Process: If the case is appealed, the percentage may rise further due to the additional legal work required.
-
Recovery Calculation Example
Suppose a client settles a personal injury claim for $100,000, and the contingency fee is 33.3%. The attorney’s fee would be:
- $33,300 (one-third of the settlement)
- The remaining $66,700 goes to the client, minus any case-related expenses.
No Win, No Fee – But What About Expenses?
A key advantage of contingency fees is that the client does not pay the attorney if they do not win the case. However, this does not necessarily mean the client pays nothing at all. While attorney fees are contingent on winning, case-related expenses and costs may be owed or waived, depending on the agreement.
How Contingency Fees Work with Statutory Attorney Fees
In some legal cases, including employment law disputes, the prevailing party may be entitled to statutory attorney fees as mandated by law. These fees are paid separately by the losing party, rather than being deducted from the client’s recovery. This can significantly impact how attorney compensation is calculated in a contingency fee arrangement.
Example of a $100,000 Recovery with Statutory Attorney Fees
Let’s assume:
- The client wins an employment law case and recovers $100,000 in damages.
- The court awards $50,000 in statutory attorney fees to be paid by the losing party.
- The contingency fee agreement states that the attorney receives 33.3% of the client’s recovery, unless statutory fees are awarded.
Scenario 1: No Statutory Fee Award
- Attorney’s fee (33.3% of $100,000) = $33,300
- Client receives: $66,700 (before case expenses deduction)
Scenario 2: Statutory Fee Award of $50,000
- The losing party is ordered to pay $50,000 in statutory attorney fees.
- Some agreements allow the attorney to take the greater of the contingency fee or the statutory fee.
- If the agreement allows the attorney to keep both, they receive:
- $50,000 statutory fee (paid by the losing party)
- $33,300 contingency fee (from the client’s recovery)
- Total attorney earnings: $83,300
- Client receives: $66,700 (before expenses)
Scenario 3: Offset or Reduction of Contingency Fee
- Some agreements offset the contingency fee by the statutory award, meaning the attorney does not double dip.
- If the attorney’s contingency fee ($33,300) is less than the $50,000 statutory award, the statutory fee replaces the contingency fee.
- The attorney receives $50,000, and the client keeps the full $100,000 settlement.
Key Considerations in Contingency Cases with Statutory Fees
- Fee Agreements Matter – Some agreements allow attorneys to collect both statutory and contingency fees, while others offset one with the other.
- Who Pays the Fees? – Statutory fees are typically paid by the losing party, meaning the client’s recovery remains intact.
- Negotiation – Clients can negotiate whether statutory fees will replace or supplement contingency fees before signing an agreement.
Advance of Costs in Contingency Fee Cases
In many contingency cases, the attorney advances litigation costs on behalf of the client, meaning the client does not have to pay these costs upfront. This can be crucial, especially in cases requiring expert testimony, medical record retrieval, or depositions.
Types of Litigation Costs Attorneys May Advance
- Court Filing Fees – The cost to file a lawsuit, which varies by jurisdiction.
- Expert Witness Fees – Some cases require expert testimony (e.g., medical experts in malpractice cases, accident reconstruction experts).
- Deposition Costs – Attorneys may depose witnesses, requiring a court reporter and transcript fees.
- Subpoenas of Record Fees – Personal injury cases often require obtaining medical records.
- Investigation and Discovery Costs – Investigators, private detectives, and discovery-related expenses such as obtaining evidence.
- Travel Expenses – Attorneys may travel to court, meet experts, or interview witnesses.
- Trial Exhibits and Demonstrations – Preparing visual or physical evidence for trial presentations.
How Are Advanced Costs Reimbursed?
When an attorney advances costs, these expenses are usually deducted from the client’s recovery before calculating the attorney’s percentage.
Example: How Costs Impact the Final Payout
- Case Settlement Amount: $100,000
- Advanced Costs: $5,000
- Attorney’s Fee (33.3% of net amount after deducting costs):
- First, deduct costs from the total: $100,000 – $5,000 = $95,000
- Then, calculate the attorney’s fee: 33.3% of $95,000 = $31,667
- The client receives: $95,000 – $31,667 = $63,333
What If the Case Is Lost?
If the case is unsuccessful, the client may or may not be responsible for repaying the advanced costs. This depends on the fee agreement:
- Some attorneys absorb the loss, meaning the client does not owe anything.
- Others require reimbursement, meaning the client must repay the advanced costs even if they do not win the case.
This is a critical point for clients to clarify before signing an agreement.
