Can previous employers give a bad reference?

There are no state or federal laws prohibiting what a previous employer can or cannot say about a former employee. However, previous employers are not permitted to make up lies to damage your reputation and make it difficult for you to get another job.

By Brad Nakase, Attorney

Email  |  Call (888) 600-8654

There is no law that prohibits former employers from providing honest opinions of a former employee’s performance to a prospective employer. If a former employer is accurate and factual in their reference, they are within their legal rights to disclose that information. However, a previous employer may not make misrepresentations or lies, making the bad job reference illegal. If your previous employer made false statements about you, you should contact our San Diego employee rights lawyer Brad Nakase to help you.

When applying for a new position, most employers ask for a resume or a list of references. During an interview, there may be a discussion about why you left your previous job. If you quit or were fired, this answer might not be on the best terms. It can be rather awkward when trying to get a new job if your old boss speaks negatively about you. A special privilege exists between a former and prospective employer, allowing your former employer to make truthful statements about your job performance and why you left it to a prospective employer. This privilege is called the “common-interest privilege.”

The common-interest privilege protects the conversations between the prospective and former employer to understand who one is hiring fully. It is in public policy’s interest to ensure employers fully discover who they are hiring and not being led under pretences. If this privilege applies, the statement made cannot be used in court for the truth against the employer. However, there are exceptions to this privilege (when this privilege will not apply):

  1. There is no protection if statements are made maliciously or with the intent to hurt one’s reputation
  2. No protection when the statements are false
  3. Unsolicited statements – statements made without being asked for information
  4. Cannot state whether the former employee engages in protected activities or belongs to certain groups

However, a former employer can always state whether they would rehire the employee.

Defamation in California

To bring a claim against a former employer for defamation, the employee must show three things:

  1. Falsity: statements made were false, unprivileged, and not an opinion
  2. Published: statements were published, meaning they were stated or written to another person
  3. Damages: the employee must show the statements made by the former employer damaged their reputation.

If you feel you have been defamed (have had false statements made about you, either in writing or orally) and have faced damages, the best option would be to speak with a lawyer before filing any claims. This will ensure you have taken the proper steps, understand the law thoroughly, and will have a better understanding of whether your claim is valid or not.

Blog: Business | Corporate | Employment Law

See all blogs: Business | Corporate | Employment

Vacation Pay in California - Rules on Accrual, Caps, and Payouts

Vacation Pay in California: Rules on Accrual, Caps, and Payouts

Get a practical overview of California vacation pay rules, including accrual methods, lawful caps, and payout obligations for departing employees. Help your company avoid wage claims by setting compliant vacation policies, tracking balances accurately, and paying unused time on separation.
Personnel File Request California - Employee Rights and Employer Duties

Personnel File Request California: Employee Rights and Employer Duties

Get a practical overview of California personnel file requests, including employee rights, employer duties, record contents, and medical privacy rules. See how deadlines, penalties, and strict documentation practices affect compliance when workers request copies of their personnel records.
Employer vs Supervisor - Differences in Roles and Responsibilities

Employer vs Supervisor: Differences in Roles and Responsibilities

Compare employer and supervisor roles, from legal responsibility to daily management, so workers see who controls policies and everyday work. Get a simple breakdown of authority, decision making, and workplace impact to clarify who to approach when issues arise.
Target policies for employees - Recruitment, Pay, Culture

Target policies for employees: Recruitment, Pay, Culture

See how Target's HR policies shape recruitment, pay, and culture to attract and retain top retail talent. Review Target's focus on training, inclusion, benefits, compliance, and HR technology to support engaged, high-performing employees.
California Law About Contacting Employees After Hours (AB 2751) - Right to Disconnect

California Law About Contacting Employees After Hours (AB 2751)

See how California's AB 2751 gives employees a right to disconnect from after-hours calls, emails, texts, and pressure. Review protections, exceptions, and timelines so workers and employers can prepare for possible changes to California work-life boundaries.
SB 553 Workplace Violence - California Prevention Law and Employer Duties

SB 553 Workplace Violence: California Prevention Law and Employer Duties

California employers must comply with SB 553 workplace violence prevention rules, including written plans, employee training, and incident recordkeeping. Stay aligned with California Labor Code 6401.9 by updating policies, supporting workers, and preparing for Cal/OSHA enforcement expectations.

Please tell us your story:

0 + 2 = ?

See all blog: Business | Corporate | Employment

926
© Copyright | Nakase Law Firm (2019)