Can I Sue My Employer For Not Paying Me Correctly?

Bruh – boss ain’t paying you? Generally, yes you may sue an employer for not paying you correctly. Employees work hard and deserve to be paid correctly, and on time. It sucks when an employee works hard, and long hours only to be paid incorrectly while the boss is driving a Lambo or Benz. As an employment attorney, employees frequently ask me, “My employer didn’t pay me what can i do.” The answer has many shades of gray.

Brad Nakase, Attorney

Email  |  Tel (888) 600-8654

You work hard for your boss to make money, and you shouldn’t have to chase after the money you earned. In America, most workers depend on the biweekly paycheck to pay rent and care for their families. Living paycheck to paycheck and working hard as much as they can. It is unacceptable when an employer does not pay their worker. It is illegal for an employer to withhold their workers’ income. It is wage theft under both federal and state laws of employment. Workers often contact me and ask, “My employer didn’t pay me what can I do?” YES, you can sue a company for not paying you. In fact, many employees contact me learn that they are also owed money for missed rest break and lunch break breaks. Please call me; I got your back.

Related blogs:

Before you can sue a company for not paying you, it is important to know which type of case to approach first and what evidence you will need. For example, what type of wage theft did your employer commit? There are different types of wage violations and theft, such as; violations in terms of minimum wage and overtime pay, requiring workers to work off the clock, and record-keeping violations.

In this article, we will discuss what you can do when your employer didn’t pay you or didn’t pay you correctly as follows:

Violations of Minimum & Overtime Pay

Employers who willfully or repeatedly violate the minimum wage or overtime pay requirements are subject to a civil money penalty. Non-exempt employees who work more than the established 40 hours are entitled to overtime pay at one-and-a-half times the normal wage. If you were paid less than the minimum wage, you are entitled to liquidated damages equal to the amount of your lost wages.

Workers have every right to sue employers if they fail to pay them the minimum wage that is mandated by federal law. There is minimum wage pay that has been set by the FLSA (Fair Labor Standards Act) and it must be paid to workers. And even though federal laws have mandated a certain minimum wage, some states have mandated an even higher minimum wage.

An employer can also fail to pay correctly by illegally deducting expenses from a worker’s paycheck when the law does not allow them to do so. Hence it is important to keep an eye on deducted money from your paycheck.

A worker can also sue their employer when they do not pay them overtime. An employer is not paying correctly if they deny their workers overtime pay as required by both state and federal laws. If an employee works more than 40 hours in a work week (7 days), federal and state laws require employers to pay overtime. When an employee makes overtime pay, it is one and a half times what they regularly get paid. A worker may be making $12 an hour, but if they work overtime, they’d be paid $18 an hour for every hour worked after working 40 hours.

It is important to note that some employees such as supervisors or managers get paid a salary instead of hourly pay. Because of this, these employees are not eligible to be paid for overtime work.

FLSA laws state that overtime pay cannot be waived by an employer nor an employee. Most of the time when an employer commits violations in overtime pay is for not classifying their worker’s job title correctly, for falsifying records in timekeeping and working locations, mistakes in calculations of working hours, and changing time clock records or undercounting hours that employees worked.

It is illegal for an employer to ask an employee to work off the clock. In most states including California, an employer can’t force you to work off-the-clock. In most states and California,  employers cannot require employees to work “off-the- clock” without monetary compensation. Employees can sue employers for requiring them to do work before they actually clock in or after they clock out for work. The employer would not only be not paying correctly, but they’d also be violating state and FLSA laws. If they are illegally forcing employees to work off the clock, they can also be liable if employees get injured while doing so. Employers could face both wage theft and personal injury claims against them.

Working off the clock can look like:

  • Employers requiring their employees to work through both their rest and lunch breaks.
  • Employers expecting their employees to do work or tasks at home.
  • Employers requiring employees to still answers to voicemails and emails before and/or after clocking in and out.
  • Employers not paying wages for their employees training.
  • Employers having workers do projects outside of work and only labeling it as volunteer work.

Violations in Record-Keeping

An employer can be sued for not paying correctly when their fail to organize and/or maintain time records (wages, working hours, compensations, etc..) accurately. The U.S. Department of Labor requires that all employers do this, and if employers deny their employees their deserving pay, they can face record-keeping violation claims.

WHD (Wage and Hour Division) posters from the U.S. Department of Labor are required to be put up in the workplace to inform employees of all the records that their employer is required to keep. Such records include the hours worked by employee, the total number of hours to be put in by employees per work week, and the hourly pay rate for employees.

How to report wage theft by employer?

When an employee files a wage claim against an employer, then they cannot be terminated by their employer for doing so. But before hiring an employment lawyer or filing a claim or getting the EEOC (Equal Employment Opportunity Commission) involved, it is important for the employee to first try and communicate with their employer regarding the issue. An employer might have miscalculated or made a mistake in their records which could be fixed.

But if an employer does not agree on a solution or even a settlement for the wage theft issue, then the employee should inform the federal agency EEOC regarding the issue by filing a claim. An employee would have a phone interview with an EEOC representative to have the right to file a claim with the EEOC. Contacting the WHD (Wage and Hour Division) with the U.S. Department of Labor is also an option.

My employer did not pay me what can I do?

If the employer didn’t pay you, you can hire an employment lawyer in Los Angeles or DIY file a complaint and report your unpaid wages to the U.S. Department of Labor’s Wage. If you’re in California, you can also file a complaint with the Labor Commissioner.  When an employee sues employer for not paying correctly, then the judicial system allows employees/plaintiffs the right to seek monetary damages that can include interest pay, back pay, punitive and compensatory damages.

Interest/Liquidated Damages: Under state laws, an employee can sue their employer for not paying wages correctly, this goes as well for unpaid wages and the interests charged. Depending on the case, employees could also see liquidated damages instead of interest pay.

  • Back Pay Recovery: Employees have the right to recover every cent owed to them by their employer that was not paying correctly either by not paying overtime or by deducting from their paycheck. To try and recover back pay, employees must have proof that they worked a certain total amount of hours at a set pay rate.

  • Punitive Damages: Several states require that employers who are not paying correctly must face a penalty. Such penalty is that on top of paying for all other damages, that employers must also pay a financial penalty. For example, in California, employers must pay 30 days of an employee’s wages as a waiting time penalty.

  • Compensatory Damages: When an employer is not paying correctly, an employee experiences distress and faces difficult and stressful times. Therefore compensatory damages can be applied to cover the pain and suffering of the employee who was wronged by their employer.

What Can an Employee Do If An Employer Is Not Paying Correctly?

An employee can suspect that their employer is not paying correctly if their paycheck does not seem right. Employees cannot assume that their employer is always right when it comes to paying correctly, most employers end up underpaying their employees either by accident or on purpose. Employees could be getting paid less than the minimum wage or be cheated out of other wages or compensations.

Things to look out for include:

  • Ensuring your paycheck is correct. One must take a closer look at their paystubs and make sure it looks like the paystub required. 

  • Ensuring that your work hours are correct. Make sure that you are not only getting paid for all the hours included in your paystub, but that all the hours you worked are in fact on the paystub.

  • Ensuring the pay rate is correct. When an employer promises an employee an hourly rate, then it must be the one used to pay the employee. The pay rate promised must be at least $7.25 per hour, which is the federal minimum wage. It is also possible that the state you are in has a higher minimum wage requirement.

  • Ensuring overtime is compensated. According to federal laws, employers must pay their employees time and a half the regular rate for overtime hours. Overtime pay is required if employees work more than 40 hours in a workweek.

  • Ensuring that all deductions are correct. An employer is required to pay all state, federal, and local income taxes on their employees’ behalf, along with Medicare and social security taxes. These are deducted from the employees’ pay, but anything else cannot be deducted from their pay. Such as uniform or equipment charges.

Once an employee has determined that their paycheck/pay-stub is incorrect and that their employer is not paying correctly, there are steps they can take:

  • Report to Employer and/or Human Resources: An employee should report the mistakes and incorrect pay right away to their boss or to HR. An employer not paying correctly could be a mistake and an issue that could be easily fixed, and the unpaid wages could be paid for right away or on the next check.

  • Keep All Records: It is important for an employee to keep note of all the times in which they arrive and leave work, along with all their break times, travel between work sites, and any prep or clean up time. Keep note of the promised rate of pay and total hours worked in a workweek. An employee must keep records to prove if their employer is or is not paying correctly.

  • Discuss With Coworkers: If an employer is not paying an employee correctly, it is more likely that they are not the only worker being paid incorrectly. It can be helpful to figure out what other workers are being affected by this issue, and it would most likely get the employer’s attention and provide protection if action is taken as a group.

  • Discuss with Boss/Employer, or Human Resources: An employee should approach their employer either individually or in a group about them not paying correctly. They must insist on being paid what they are owed in wages.

  • Filing a Claim/Complaint: Employees must file a complaint with the Department of Labor’s Wage & Hour Division if their employer refuses to act or respond to their payment concerns. They must make a complaint concerning the wage theft and not being paid correctly their minimum wage or overtime.

  • Contact an Employment Lawyer: An employee has every right to sue employer for not paying correctly and violating state and federal laws on wage and hour. This can be done either individually or in a group of coworkers (class action). These lawsuits can be filed and made easier with the assistance of an employment attorney.

Please tell us your story:

4 + 0 = ?

How to establish a Performance Improvement Plan

How to establish a Performance Improvement Plan

A Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) addresses behavioral issues and unmet objectives to enhance performance. This guide covers assessing the need, creating, implementing, tracking, and concluding a PIP effectively.
FLSA status - Non-exempt vs. Exempt

FLSA status: Exempt vs. Non-exempt

FLSA status classifies employees as non-exempt or exempt, affecting overtime pay eligibility. This ensures compliance with labor laws and protects workers' rights.
What is a disciplinary action

What is a disciplinary action?

Disciplinary action involves measures against employees for misbehavior or poor performance. Managers decide appropriate actions based on the infraction's severity, ensuring fairness.
HR Manager Interview Questions

HR Manager Interview Questions

Prepare for your HR manager interview with insights on key questions, ensuring you present your best qualities and understand role-specific expectations. Equip yourself with responses that highlight your experience and alignment with the company's values.
New Employee Orientation Guide

New Employee Orientation Guide

Optimize new employee orientation with our guide on strategies and benefits; learn how to implement the ROPES model for effective onboarding.
Job Requisition Meaning

Job Requisition Meaning

A job requisition is an official request to open a new position within a company. This article defines job requisitions, their significance, and essential components.
Automation in HR - Streamline efficiency

Automation in HR: Streamline efficiency

HR automation speeds up routine tasks, allowing HR teams to focus on strategic initiatives and employee engagement. This technology enhances efficiency, reduces errors, and improves overall workplace satisfaction.
Graphic Rating Scale in HR

Graphic Rating Scale in HR

The graphic rating scale is a straightforward tool for evaluating employee performance based on specific qualities and behaviors. It offers simplicity, cost-effectiveness, and ease of understanding but can suffer from subjectivity and biases.
Titles for HR - Key job roles

Titles for HR: Key job roles

Explore key HR job roles, salary ranges, and essential qualifications in the expanding human resources field. Learn about popular HR positions and chart your career path in this dynamic industry.
People analytics - Importance and benefits

People analytics: Importance and benefits

People analytics is crucial for data-driven HR decisions, improving workforce planning and talent management. Organizations like Google and NASA use it to enhance recruitment, performance, and employee engagement.
What is DEIB - Key concepts explained

What is DEIB: Key concepts explained

Understand DEIB (Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging) and its impact on business success. Discover strategies to promote DEIB in your organization.
Clan culture - Building organizational unity

Clan culture: Building organizational unity

Discover the benefits of clan culture in organizations, emphasizing loyalty, teamwork, and flexible management. Learn how this collaborative environment enhances employee engagement and organizational success.
Learning vs. Training - Key differences

Learning vs. Training: Key differences

Distinguish between learning and training in the workplace. Learning involves continuous skill development, while training focuses on specific task instruction for immediate job needs.
Organizational commitment - Key strategies

Organizational commitment: Key strategies

Organizational commitment boosts employee morale, productivity, and reduces turnover, leading to a more effective business. Learn key strategies to foster commitment, including clear communication, job satisfaction, and fair compensation.
Skill will matrix

Skill Will Matrix

The Skill Will Matrix is a powerful tool for leaders to enhance talent management and employee engagement. This article details how the matrix helps managers tailor interactions based on employees' skills and motivation, driving improved performance and productivity.
Skills building - Empowering employees' growth

Skills building: Empowering employees’ growth

Enhance your organization's success by empowering employees' growth through targeted skill development. Equip your team with essential competencies to fill talent gaps and ensure long-term business growth.
Recruitment KPIs - Essential metrics guide

Recruitment KPIs: Essential metrics guide

Track essential recruitment KPIs to optimize your hiring strategy and measure success effectively. Learn which KPIs to monitor and how to align them with your company's objectives.
HR compliance - Ensuring legal safety

HR compliance: Ensuring legal safety

Ensure your company's legality and protect your workers by maintaining HR compliance with federal and state regulations. HR compliance helps prevent liabilities, fines, and controversies, safeguarding your company's reputation.
Compa ratio - Understanding competitive pay

Compa ratio: Understanding competitive pay

Use the compa ratio to evaluate competitive pay by comparing employee salaries to wage range midpoints. Ensure fair compensation and make informed payroll decisions for your organization.
People management - Key to business success

People management: Key to business success

Effective people management boosts employee retention, engagement, and productivity, directly enhancing business performance. Learn about the challenges, key competencies, and best practices for successful people management.
Model of team effectiveness

Model of team effectiveness

A team effectiveness model provides a roadmap to enhance team operations and support their development. Explore various models to determine which best improves team understanding and performance.
Merit increase meaning

Merit increase meaning

A merit increase is a pay raise given for exceptional work and contributions to company goals. It differs from a raise, promotion, and bonus by being a permanent salary boost based on performance.
Non-monetary incentives - Top employee rewards

Non-monetary incentives: Top employee rewards

Employee rewards extend beyond cash, keeping enthusiasm and motivation high with non-monetary incentives. Discover the best non-monetary rewards to enhance engagement and boost company culture.
Employee engagement plan

Employee Engagement Plan

Create a concrete employee engagement plan to boost staff morale and productivity. Enhance employee satisfaction and improve company performance with targeted initiatives.
Offboarding checklist - Ensure smooth transitions

Offboarding checklist: Ensure smooth transitions

Ensure smooth transitions with our offboarding checklist, guiding you through essential steps for a successful process. Reduce legal risks, preserve goodwill, and safeguard your company's reputation with a thorough offboarding procedure.
HR report - Benefits and metrics

HR report: Benefits and metrics

HR reports and dashboards are essential for effective HR decision-making and workforce management. This article highlights their benefits, key metrics, and the importance of automated, accurate reporting.
Termination policy - Key elements to include

Termination policy: Key elements to include

Ensure a smooth and respectful employee exit with a clear termination policy that outlines essential procedures. Protect your business from legal issues and provide transparency for all employees during the termination process.