Introduction
The criminal background check procedure used by employers for California job applicants and staff members has undergone major changes as a result of new legislation that went into effect on 1st October 2023. The California Fair Chance Act will be expanded by the new background check laws in California, as explained in the following responses to nine commonly asked questions.
Quick Points
- Employers will have to perform a more thorough examination utilizing new evaluation variables before making unfavorable employment judgments based on criminal record history under the newly implemented California background check regulations.
- Damages include back wages, front wages, and hiring or reinstatement if the additional criminal evaluation elements are not taken into account.
- California’s new background check laws went into force on 1st October 2023
Question 1: California background check laws: What are the objectives?
Answer 1: Before making unfavorable hiring judgments based on a candidate’s criminal conviction record, employers must implement a new procedure that includes a more thorough study using new evaluation elements.
Question 2: Which new evaluation criteria should companies take into account?
Answer 2: According to the revised rules, employers must take into account the following sub-factors:
- The applicant’s particular personal behavior that led to the conviction
- Whether people or property were harmed
- The extent of the damage (the amount of money lost due to theft)
- The damage’s enduring nature
- The circumstances surrounding the offense
- Whether a disability (drug abuse/mental illness history) played a role in the offense/behavior. If a reasonable adjustment might sufficiently lessen or completely remove the possibility of injury from comparable behavior.
- How old was the petitioner when the behavior took place
- Whether sexual assault, human trafficking, stalking, trauma, dating or domestic violence, duress, or other comparable circumstances had a role in the infraction/behavior
- The duration since the behavior that led to the charge. It may have occurred much earlier than the conviction itself.
- How long has it been since the applicant was released from prison (post the conviction that resulted in jail)?
- The particular tasks involved in the job
- Whether the circumstances surrounding the conviction are likely to recur in the workplace, or
- Whether the kind or extent of the harm brought about by the sentence is likely to happen there.
The new rules also mandate that employers take into account whatever proof they may have of a worker’s or applicant’s rehabilitation and favorable conditions, some of which include the aforementioned.
Question 3: A few of the new assessment criteria deal with delicate subjects, such as alcoholism & domestic violence. How do we adhere to the current background check laws and the safeguards for protected characteristics, such as past alcoholism?
Answer 3: The two types of requirements are in tension. Some businesses are informing candidates and staff members of the criteria and urging them to provide pertinent information, but they are not explicitly requesting or requiring the supply of such details.
Question 4: Pre-adverse action letters are reportedly being used by certain employers to meet the new regulations. Does that have to be done?
Answer 4: Although California hasn’t dealt with this strategy, it appears to be a reasonable way to deal with the new California requirements to use a series of pre-adverse response letters to fulfill the California and federal requirements (including communicating and soliciting details on the new assessment factors and the conventional three federal elements). As time goes on, we may learn more, gain greater familiarity with these new standards, and/or receive additional direction.
Question 5: What penalties result from neglecting to take into account the recently added California background check laws?
Answer 5: The similar damages that apply to infractions of the Fair Employment and Housing Act. It can include back wages, front wages, penalties for mental anguish, monetary punishment, reinstatement or hiring, and promotion. Out-of-pocket costs, modifications to policies, education, reasonable accommodations, and legal fees may also result from neglecting the new laws.
Question 6: For people who work, reside, or both in Los Angeles, do the relevant background check laws apply?
Answer 6: The City of Los Angeles legislation applies to workers who spend at least 2 hours a week on average in Los Angeles. It includes individuals who work online from their homes in the city for firms that are based in or conduct operations in Los Angeles.
Question 7: Can businesses take into account California applicants’ & employees’ sex offender registry data?
Answer 7: In general, companies might not take into account data from a sex offender registry that they or their background record check vendors discover. However, employers may take into account criminal convictions (which might also appear on the registry) that were discovered in another way, such as via a criminal background check. These convictions are listed in the background check report’s “convictions” section rather than the “sex offender registry” section, and the data is reviewed using the new California, federal, and applicable area evaluation factors.
Question 8: Why have background checks in California been so delayed, particularly in recent years?
Answer 8: Driver’s license numbers & dates of birth in court documents were almost completely unavailable to the general population, including investigation vendors and consumer reporting agencies (CRAs), as a result of a court ruling and Governor Gavin Newsom’s consequent veto of a measure passed to address the matter (2022).
Because of this, it has been extremely difficult for CRAs to confirm the names of criminal defendants in local court searches, which severely restricts their capacity to submit criminal records and causes employers to be far slower to get the findings of background checks.
Question 9: Can I obtain information without an official background check by simply searching the internet?
Answer 9: Whether they find out about an applicant’s or employee’s conviction record from a background check provider, consumer reporting entity, or through another source, employers must take into account the new evaluation criteria and do the necessary analysis in accordance with the new California requirements. Employers’ use of online searches on California candidates and workers is likewise subject to those rules and regulations.