When did tips become taxable?

Tips became taxable in 1965 when legislation extending Social Security coverage to tips (for both taxation and the calculation of retirement benefits), required a tipped employee to report monthly all such tips received in one or more written statements furnished to his employer.

By Brad Nakase, Attorney

Email  |  Call (888) 600-8654

Have a quick question? I answered nearly 1500 FAQs.

The Taxability of Tips: A Historical Overview

The original income tax statute of 1913 included “compensation for personal service of whatever kind and in whatever form paid,” which certainly seemed expansive enough to encompass tips. The practice of tipping began in Tudor England. In medieval times, tipping was a master-serf custom wherein a servant would receive extra money for having performed superbly well.

Treasury declared in a 1919 regulation that “commissions paid salesmen, compensation for services on the basis of profits, commissions on insurance premiums, tips, retired pay of federal and other officers, and pensions or retiring allowances paid by the United States or private persons, are income to the recipients.” The legal recognition of tips as taxable income played a significant role in solidifying their tax treatment. In the United States, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) established in 1963 that tips received by service employees were to be treated as taxable income, akin to wages and salaries.

Legal Developments and Codification

The issue of taxation on tip income became a matter of concern for governments. In the United States, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) first addressed the taxation of tips in 1963. The IRS established that tips received by service employees were considered taxable income, just like wages and salaries. By including tips in the definition of wages for tax purposes, it acknowledges that tips should be treated no differently from regular wages and salaries.

The legal affirmation of the taxable status of tips came through several pivotal cases. In Roberts v. Commissioner, a 1948 Tax Court case, the court ruled that tips were taxable income rather than tax-exempt gifts. Only in 1948 did the statutory interpretation question finally receive judicial attention. Harry Roberts, a Los Angeles taxicab driver who had received a notice of deficiency based on unreported tip income, argued in Tax Court that tips were tax-free gifts rather than taxable compensation for services and that the contrary regulation was invalid.

The Supreme Court reinforced this view in the 1960 Duberstein opinion, describing tips as “classic examples” of taxable “payment . . . in return for services rendered.” Judicial confirmation of the taxability of tips was further solidified in later rulings.

The 1982 TEFRA Act and Enforcement Challenges

As part of the 1982 Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act, large restaurants were required to report taxable tips for their employees, regardless of whether those tips had actually been received by servers. According to the IRS, estimates showed that employees reported less than 20 percent of their tip income.

Many of the letter writers were incredulous, insisting that tips were actually tax-free gifts. As I recall, that was the prevailing sentiment at Allen’s Clam House, too. After decades of underenforcement by the IRS, waiters had come to believe that this view of tips was all but universal; tax-free tips were a right, they believed, even if lawmakers were claiming otherwise.

A fellow paid a $20 dinner check and tipped the waiter $1. The waiter spurned the tip, and loftily explained that it represented only 5 percent of the check; the minimum in that establishment is 10 percent (and even that isn’t considered any too much these days). “Very interesting,” murmured the customer, flashing his credentials as a representative of the Bureau of Internal Revenue.

Ongoing Controversies and Tipping Culture

The rationale behind taxing tips encompasses multiple factors. First and foremost, consistency in the tax treatment of income is essential. Treating all forms of income equally helps maintain fairness and prevents preferential treatment of certain types of earnings. One of the worst things about the tax-free tip proposals is how ineffective they would be at actually helping tipped workers. Many tips currently go unreported as income, and the lost revenue from an exemption is hard to estimate.

Taxing tips ensures consistency in the treatment of income. From a tax policy perspective, it is crucial to treat all forms of income equally to maintain fairness and prevent preferential treatment of certain types of earnings. Another crucial aspect of taxing tips is the prevention of tax evasion and underreporting of income. Tips, often paid in cash, provide individuals with an opportunity to underreport or completely evade taxes on their tip income.

Proposals to Change Taxation of Tips

Donald Trump, by his own account inspired by a chance conversation with a Las Vegas waitress, announced a new campaign pledge: “No taxes on tips.” In 2024, both major presidential candidates endorsed proposals to make tips tax-free, reflecting a shift in public and political attitudes toward tipping. Trump’s plan for an expansive and comprehensive exclusion, available to all workers, possibly extending to payroll as well as income taxes, has been compared to Kamala Harris’s approach. Harris seems to favor a more limited version of the idea, restricting the exclusion to workers in the service and hospitality industries and providing for both an income limit and a cap on the amount of the excludable income.

The Historical and Social Roots of Tipping

Historians trace tipping in the United States back to the post-Civil War era, when the practice gained traction as a way to provide gratuities to service workers. What started as an unethical loophole to the 13th amendment turned into a financial opportunity where restaurateurs benefited by subsidizing hourly pay with gratuities — and took off in becoming a standard practice across the U.S. and influencing the tipping culture that is alive and well today.

Conclusion

By explicitly taxing tips and implementing reporting requirements, tax authorities can minimize the opportunity for tax evasion and ensure that individuals accurately report their income. Today, the ongoing debate over the fairness and practicality of taxing tips underscores the need for continued dialogue on balancing equity, compliance, and economic realities.

Have a quick question? We answered nearly 2000 FAQs.

See all blogs: Business | Corporate | Employment Law

Most recent blogs:

Can Managers Receive Tips in California? No.

Can Managers Receive Tips in California? No. Under California law, a manager cannot take any part of a tip that's left for an employee. This means that you can't be forced to share your tips with the manager, supervisor, or owner of the business.  In California, when an employer or another supervisor or manager takes an employee's tips, it is considered a wage and hour violation.

Can Managers Take Tips In California?

No, in California, it is strictly prohibited for your manager to take tips that are intended for employees. California labor laws clearly state that tips are the sole property of the employees to whom they are given, and managers, supervisors, or employers cannot collect, share, or deduct any portion of these gratuities.

Lawyer Answers FAQ: California Lunch Break Law and Meal Break Law

Most California workers must receive the following breaks: An uninterrupted 30-minute unpaid meal break when working more than five hours in a day. As a general rule, and insofar as practicable, the rest break must be in the middle of each four-hour work period.

When did tips become taxable?

Tips became taxable in 1965 when legislation extending Social Security coverage to tips (for both taxation and the calculation of retirement benefits), required a tipped employee to report monthly all such tips received in one or more written statements furnished to his employer.
Is Job Abandonment Considered a Resignation in California

Is Job Abandonment Considered a Resignation in California?

Job abandonment in California is viewed as voluntary resignation when employees fail to notify their employer after extended absences. Employers should implement clear policies, address legitimate exceptions, and follow labor laws to manage job abandonment appropriately

California Lunch Break Law [2025]

This article answers common questions, such as "How many hours do you have to work to get a lunch break?" and "Can I work 6 hours without a lunch break in California?" Under California law, employees must be provided with no less than a thirty-minute lunch break when the work period is more than five hours. In California, an employer may not employ an employee for a work period of more than five hours per day without providing the employee with a lunch break.
Overtime - Understanding California’s laws and employee rights

Overtime: Understanding California’s laws and employee rights

California's overtime laws require non-exempt employees to receive extra pay for working over 8 hours a day or 40 hours a week. Employees must be compensated at 1.5 times their regular rate for hours beyond these limits and double pay for excessive hours on the 7th consecutive workday.

Why would someone ask for their personnel file?

Employees who believe they have been fired as a result of unlawful discrimination, retaliation, or harassment will often request their personnel file. Those files may contain information that helps you prove discrimination, harassment, or other civil rights violations.

Can You Refuse to Work If You Haven’t Been Paid?

Legally, you may have the right to refuse work if your employer hasn't paid you because it is constructive termination and wage theft by the employer. If your employer hasn't paid you, should should review your contract before not working.

What Happens If I Don’t Get Paid on Payday?

If you don't get paid on payday, contact an employment attorney immediately and ask for help getting the wages owed to you. Alternatively, if the regular payday for the last pay period an employee worked has passed and the employee has not been paid, contact the Department of Labor's Wage and Hour Division or the state labor department. 

How long can an employer not pay you?

Your employer must pay you on pay day if you did not resign or fired from your job. If you're fired from your job, you must be paid the same day. If you quit your job, you must be paid within 3 days. 

Do You Get Paid for Training? 

In California, employees are generally entitled to be paid for training as long as its job-related and mandated by the employer.

Is Unpaid Training Legal in California?

Yes, unpaid training is illegal in California. California employers must pay for mandatory training. Employees not paid for meetings or job training can sue for unpaid training.

Is It Illegal To Not Pay Overtime?

Yes, it is illegal for employer to not pay overtime. Overtime pay is 1.5 times an employee's regular rate of pay. Not all employees are eligible for overtime.
Is It Illegal to Work Seven Days a Week

Is It Illegal to Work Seven Days a Week?

Working seven days a week varies by state, with California laws addressing rest days and overtime pay rules. Employers must ensure compliance with labor laws to guarantee proper compensation and protect employee wellbeing.
How Many Hours per Week Is Considered Full Time

How Many Hours per Week Is Considered Full Time?

Find out what constitutes full-time employment, typical workweek lengths, and the benefits of full-time jobs, including health insurance and PTO. Learn how employers define full-time hours, overtime rules, and requirements for family leave under FMLA.

How To Report A Company Paying Employees Under The Table

If you are an employee being paid under the table, you can make a whistleblower report by contacting attorney Brad Nakase. Attorney Nakase does not charge an upfront fee and works on a contingency basis, collecting a percentage of the recovery. This ensures you can pursue your claim without financial barriers.

Contact our attorney.

Please tell us your story:

1 + 0 = ?