Interview Guides: How to conduct effective job candidate interviews

Review the benefits of using an interview guide to streamline candidate evaluations and ensure a consistent interview process across your organization. Delve into the seven essential components that make up an effective interview guide.

By Brad Nakase, Attorney

Email  |  Call (888) 600-8654

Have a quick question? I answered nearly 1500 FAQs.

How to interview candidates for a job

During the candidate interview process, an interview guide can be a very helpful resource. We’ll guide you through the interview guide in this article. We’ll discuss the advantages of using one, as well as the seven essential components of an interview guide.

A document known as an interview guide helps companies organize the way they interview candidates. It makes interviewers more aware of what questions to ask and when, and it guarantees that every applicant will have the same experience.

The interview guide’s content will vary based on your particular organizational requirements, the interview style you choose, and the function you are hiring for, among other factors.

Why using an interview guide is beneficial

There are various advantages to using an interview guide during the employment process.

An organized process: Structure is created when all interviewers go through the same stages in the same order. Consequently, there is a decreased likelihood of individuals overlooking to ask specific questions of applicants or provide them with specific information.

Experience of the candidate: All candidates will have the same experience if they follow an interview guide. There will always be differences because no two interviewers are the same, but at least the questions and procedure are the same for everybody.

Equal evaluation: You can evaluate candidates using the same scoring system if you employ the same interviewing technique and ask each one of the candidates the same questions. In the interview process, this lowers the possibility of bias.

Example interview guide: seven essential components

Your interview guide should ideally be a component of a carefully thought-out hiring procedure. It is therefore consistent with each step of that procedure.

This means that the interview guide should, for example, include the requirements for a new position as stated in the job description (i.e., the necessary abilities, personality, and skills of a potential candidate) to be considered during the interview. Let’s examine the seven essential components of an interview guide.

  1. Briefing and Invitation

Ensure that each candidate who advances to the interview stage receives an identical invitation that includes an explanation of what to expect during the interview (e.g., how many people they will speak with, how long it will likely take, if they need to prepare anything beforehand, what paperwork they must bring, etc.).

This is an illustration of how the email inviting someone to an interview can seem:

Subject Line: Sunshine Corp.: Interview Availability

Hi Steve,

Thank you for applying to the Sales Representative role at Sunshine Corp. We’ve carefully reviewed your application, and we’re pleased to invite you to interview for the position! 

Your interview will be conducted via Zoom and last roughly one hour. You’ll be speaking with Samantha, our HR Manager, and Kyle, our Sales Team Leader here at Sunshine Corp. 

Please let us know when you are available during the following times:

[Day, date – time, timezone]

[Day, date – time, timezone]

[Day, date – time, timezone]

Don’t forget to bring your [paperwork] and the [sample test] you prepared.

Thanks again for your interest in joining the Sunshine Corp team! We’re looking forward to speaking with you.

Best,

Melissa Robles 

mrobles@sunshinecorp.com 

The specifics and tenor of your interview invitation may vary, of course, but the sections in between brackets should always be mentioned. You can link to your company’s interview invitation template—ideally kept in Google Drive or a comparable platform—in your interview guide to ensure that every candidate receives a comprehensive invitation.

  1. Laying the groundwork

This is a real-world problem. Where would you like to conduct interviews? Who will conduct the candidate interviews? Where’s the best spot to call if it’s a video interview? To ensure that every applicant has the same experience, it is also a good idea to have the same settings for each one of them. Your interview guide should provide the “setting” requirements for both online and offline interactions.

If the interview guide, a copy of the candidate’s résumé, a copy of a work sample the candidate had to create, or any other type of document, is required of the interviewers, it should be included in the guide as well.

  1. Salutations

When welcome applicants, there are undoubtedly some things you should make sure to say. They could be about anything—the business, the past of the organization, the workplace, the job, etc. Provide the interview guide with the interview opening and all the necessary topics to cover.

  1. Questions

Standardized interview questions are employed in organized interviews. This gives the interviewer a standardized way to record data and rate the candidate’s qualifications consistently. Additionally, it gives the interviewer the ability to fairly evaluate candidates and make the best choice possible based on information.

In addition to using standardized questions, the STAR method is a frequently employed technique in interviews. This approach provides an organized means of obtaining data from the applicant. STAR represents:

Situation: Inquire about the candidate’s circumstances.

Task: What objective did the applicant seek to achieve?

Action: Inquire about the steps the candidate took to finish the work and make the most out of the circumstances.

Result: Ask the candidate about what the result they achieved and what they took away from the exercise.

It is strongly advised to use the STAR technique to assess critical competences required for the position. By posing the identical question to every applicant, you can quickly assess how much experience everyone has in these crucial areas.

This is also when it becomes crucial to coordinate the many aspects of your hiring process. The interview guide’s questions ought to include the essential abilities and capabilities outlined in the job description.

  1. Questions for candidates

There should be a section on applicant questions in your interview handbook. Towards the conclusion of the interview, the interviewer typically asks the candidate if they have any questions on the position, the business, the team, etc. People’s questions, if they ask any at all, can reveal a lot about their interest in a position with your company.

  1. Conclusion

A few things to consider before bidding a candidate farewell. Thank them for their time first of all. Second, let them know what has to happen next. When will they find out if they advanced to the next round of the selection process, what that round is, and how will they get in contact with you (by phone, email, etc.)? Thirdly, find out who their references are and how to get in touch with them, if you haven’t already done so earlier in the process. You can use this to aid in your reference check. Fourth, inform them of who to contact and how to get in touch with you if they have any concerns after they depart.

Make sure your interview guide has all of these information.

  1. Scores

It’s time to rate the candidate after the real interview has ended and they have left. What was their overall performance on each question? While the interview and the applicant’s responses are still fresh in their minds, the interviewer should immediately fill in these ratings (if they haven’t already).

There are other categories into which the interview questions can be separated, including person-job and person-organization fit. In the former, questions are meant to ascertain a candidate’s suitability for the job’s needs. In the latter, questions are meant to ascertain a candidate’s suitability for the organization (and its culture).

The type of role you’re hiring for will determine the questions you ask about person-job fit, but not as much about person-organization fit. As a result, you may choose to just incorporate those in your interview guide. If not, you can want to include a link to a Google Drive account (or a comparable service) where you save these kinds of interview questions.

To sum up

One of the best ways to make sure interviewers handle all applicants equally is to use an interview guide. It facilitates the process of evaluating and scoring candidates and is a useful tool for establishing structure during candidate interviews. The specifics of the interview guide will vary depending on the organization and the function, but the seven components this article lists provide a good starting point.

Familiarizing yourself with various types of interviews can significantly improve your approach to interviewing candidates.

Have a quick question? We answered nearly 2000 FAQs.

See all blogs: Business | Corporate | Employment Law

Most recent blogs:

An Overview of California’s Sick Leave Laws

An Overview of California’s Sick Leave Laws

California's new sick leave law mandates a minimum of 40 hours or five days of paid sick leave annually. Businesses must ensure compliance with updated regulations affecting accrual, usage, and employee protections statewide.
How Many Hours of Sick Pay Do Employees get in California

How Many Hours of Sick Pay Do Employees get in California

California’s SB616 law increases paid sick leave to a minimum of 40 hours, covering most employees, including part-timers. Employers must comply with detailed accrual, notification, and carry-over rules to meet the new legal standards.
What You Need to Know About Sick Time in California

What You Need to Know About Sick Time in California

California's new paid sick time law increases required leave from 3 to 5 days starting January 1, 2024. Employers must update policies to comply with Senate Bill 616, ensuring employees receive expanded sick leave benefits.
California Double Time - When and How it Applies

California Double Time: When and How it Applies

California’s unique double-time pay rules ensure workers receive fair compensation for extended hours and consecutive workdays. Learn about eligibility, calculations, and scenarios for double overtime in this comprehensive guide.
How is PTO Accrued in California

How is PTO Accrued in California?

California's PTO accrual laws ensure fair workplace practices, outlining employee rights to earned and accrued vacation pay. Employers must adhere to regulations on PTO caps, termination payouts, and equitable vacation policies.
How Does the Law for Breast Pumping At Work in California Work

How Does the Law for Breast Pumping At Work in California Work

California protects breastfeeding employees with strict laws, requiring employers to provide private lactation spaces and reasonable break times. Employees can file complaints or lawsuits if denied proper accommodations, ensuring comprehensive workplace support for nursing mothers.
Which Law Prevents Age Discrimination in the Workplace

Which Law Prevents Age Discrimination in the Workplace

Protect employees from age-based workplace discrimination with insights into ADEA protections and key warning signs of ageism. This article outlines employer responsibilities, legal options, and practical solutions to foster an inclusive work environment.
How Does Short-Term Disability Work for Employees

How Does Short-Term Disability Work for Employees?

Short-term disability provides employees financial security during non-work-related illnesses or injuries, offering partial income replacement. Employers can boost retention and morale through effective short-term disability benefits tailored to their workforce needs.
How Often Do You Get Paid on Disability in California

How Often Do You Get Paid on Disability in California

California disability pay provides income support, covering 60-70% of wages based on your highest-earning quarter. Benefits are paid biweekly, with eligibility determined by base period income and specific circumstances.

I Quit My Job and Never Got My Last Paycheck: California’s Last Paycheck Law

California has strict laws to protect employees and ensure they receive all owed wages promptly after leaving a job, whether they quit or were fired. This article explains the rules about your last paycheck, answers common questions, and provides examples to clarify what California’s last paycheck law means for you.

What is Good Cause for Termination?

Termination for cause requires a fair, honest reason aligned with California labor laws. Courts assess terminations to ensure they meet "good cause" standards, protecting both employer discretion and employee rights.

Contact our attorney.

Please tell us your story:

6 + 2 = ?