How to establish a Performance Improvement Plan

A Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) addresses behavioral issues and unmet objectives to enhance performance. This guide covers assessing the need, creating, implementing, tracking, and concluding a PIP effectively.

By Brad Nakase, Attorney

Email  |  Call (888) 600-8654

Have a quick question? I answered nearly 1500 FAQs.

Introduction

A worker with performance inadequacies can be given the chance to succeed via a PIP (performance improvement plan, additionally referred to as the performance action plan. It can be used to deal with behavioral concerns or situations in which specific work objectives are not fulfilled.

The outcome can be better overall performance, the discovery of a skill or training gap, or possible job actions like promotion, termination, or transfer.

Among HR’s responsibilities are:

  • Assessing whether or not a performance improvement plan is the best course to take in the given circumstance
  • Using the manager’s assistance when administering each PIP to avoid bias
  • Continuing to mentor the employee and manager during the plan

1. Ascertain whether a PIP is necessary

Instead of being used as a means by which a manager who is frustrated can begin the termination process, a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) should be utilized when there is a willingness to assist the worker in improving.

When utilized for the first purpose, it’s merely an unnecessary paper trail that informs all staff members that no such assistance is offered. HR needs to decide if a planned approach with deadlines is the better option or if a PIP would end up doing more harm than good.

HR ought to take the following into account when considering if a performance improvement plan is necessary:

  • Can a genuine behavioral or performance issue be verified? Request a list of the staff member’s shortcomings from the management, complete with dates, particular information, thorough justifications, and any prior coaching that was provided. To determine whether the problem is new or persistent, examine the most recently completed evaluation. Is a PIP required because the manager did not perform up to par?
  • Are the manager’s intentions centered toward firing the employee, in your opinion, or are they devoted to seeing the worker succeed? It may be challenging to determine this, but pay attention to whether the boss is genuinely worried about the worker and wants to support them, or if they are at their breaking point and are unable to handle the circumstance any longer.

    Insecure supervisors fail to realize that managing entails helping and developing staff members, or they might feel intimidated by certain employee actions. There is not much point in initiating a Performance Improvement Plan if the boss does not want the staff to succeed.

  • Is it possible to “repair” the problem with a structured improvement plan? A systematic method that assists in determining the reasons behind the inadequacies may be appropriate for addressing issues related to quantity targets, quality ratings, sales goals, and other related concerns. Conversely, disobedient and arrogant behaviors may not be amenable to change through the goal-oriented procedure of a PIP.
  • Does it seem that the worker has had the training necessary to do the job well? The individual could not have had access to training or informational meetings afterward due to a period of leave or other time off. To remedy the error, more training might be necessary.
  • Is there a recognized personal matter influencing the worker’s performance? Employee performance may decline when personal issues arise, although employers frequently make accommodations for this. In the event that the acceptable period for accommodations has elapsed, a PIP could assist a capable worker in refocusing and getting back on course.

2. Create a Draft Strategy

After the necessity of a PIP is determined, ask the manager to design the plan so HR may review it. An acceptable performance improvement plan should include:

  • Details on satisfactory outcome thresholds and the ways in which the employee’s present performance falls short. It is necessary to provide specifics about the unsatisfactory performance, such as dates, information, and thorough justifications. To elaborate on expectations, include the job profile and any applicable employer policies.
  • Goals that are time-bound, relevant, measurable, and attainable. The duration of PIPs is typically thirty days, sixty days, or ninety days, based on the amount of time it would require to fix the particular problem. A few examples could be:
  1. a) May, June, & July require Jane Smith to create 150 units or more per month and to have quality defects of no more than 3 percent.
  2. b) With the possible exception of authorized absences for family or medical reasons, John Smith must maintain perfect attendance throughout this ninety-day performance evaluation. He must consequently arrive at work promptly, be prepared for work at the beginning of each planned shift, and finish the whole shift at work after taking all necessary breaks.
  • Advice on the actions or resources that management will take—such as providing more resources, mentoring, or training—to help the employee meet these objectives.
  • Information on the frequency of meetings between the management and the workers to review work. This is typically carried out once a week, though it can change based on the situation.
  • There are explicit penalties for not achieving the plan’s goals. Demotion, moving to a new position, or firing are among the options.

3. Review of the plan

After reviewing the plan, HR ought to make sure that there is no prejudice against the worker. Is the functioning issue adequately described and supported? Are the deadlines reasonable and the goals fair? Is a sales representative, for instance, given a sales target that significantly exceeds the clients’ anticipated sales?

Is the staff member receiving the right resources and instruction to help them grow? Was there a sufficient onboarding process in place, if the person is relatively new, to aid in their adjustment? Should HR play a part in establishing those guidelines, the procedure ought to begin right away. Ensuring that the approach is realistic and equitable, rather than merely a way to fire an employee, is crucial to this phase.

4. Plan Implementation

The employee and you should get together to go over the strategy and expectations. Even though these are unpleasant sessions, it is beneficial if the management expresses their own dedication to the strategy and the success of the worker.

To help find areas of uncertainty and to promote ownership, it should be urged for employees to provide feedback. Be willing to adjust the plan in response to employee feedback; a valued employee’s perspective—one that merits a PIP’s time and effort—may result in a more successful strategy.

The management may alter the strategy after a thorough discussion and consideration of employee input. Following HR’s evaluation of any modifications, the manager and worker must endorse the final plan, which should then be sent to HR for confirmation.

If, at this stage, the employee is unwilling to participate in the PIP procedure, the employer must decide whether to fire the employee, demote them, or take other suitable managerial action.

5. Track the Development of the Plan

It is the manager’s responsibility to make sure that all development meetings are planned and held on time. The manager would come out as unimportant and uncommitted if they called off meetings or arrived late. Goal development should be tracked and reviewed in order to determine what factors have contributed to or hindered advances.

As soon as it becomes clear that there are training or equipment shortfalls, fill them. Encourage staff members to take the lead in these sessions, to provide feedback on how they feel they are performing, what insights they may have gained, and what more they think they need to achieve.

An employee should be encouraged to continue improving if they make effective strides toward their objective.

6. Plan Conclusion

When a worker meets plan objectives and responds well, perhaps ahead of the plan’s end date, the employer ought to formally conclude the PIP, acknowledge the worker’s accomplishments, and grant the worker permission to stay on the job. Although it’s a happy event for them, the manager needs to make sure they know that good work is expected of them going forward.

A possible reassignment, demotion, or dismissal should be explored depending on the unique circumstances if a worker’s performance worsens or they have no ability to improve, in which case the PIP must be closed.

Extending the schedule to give the employee a little more time to achieve may be beneficial if they are dedicated to improving but don’t meet the goals within the given time frame. A successful conclusion to the plan may also result from the accomplishment of improvements, even if the targets were later determined to be unrealistic or not entirely within the worker’s control.

Have a quick question? We answered nearly 2000 FAQs.

See all blogs: Business | Corporate | Employment Law

Most recent blogs:

When Is a Doctor's Note Required for Work

When Is a Doctor’s Note Required for Work?

Employers can request a doctor’s note for extended absences or workplace accommodations but must follow privacy laws and legal restrictions. Employees have rights protecting their medical information, ensuring confidentiality and preventing workplace discrimination related to health-related absences.
What Is Considered Full-Time Employment in California

What Is Considered Full-Time Employment in California?

California does not have a fixed definition of full-time employment, but federal guidelines set thresholds between 30 and 40 hours weekly. Full-time status impacts benefits, overtime eligibility, and legal protections, with employer policies differing based on industry and regulations.
Do Employers Verify Doctor's Notes in California

Do Employers Verify Doctor’s Notes in California?

California employers can verify certain details of a doctor's note but cannot access medical records without consent. Employees have rights under HIPAA, FMLA, and state laws, protecting medical privacy and ensuring job security in specific situations.
How do you properly fire an employee in California

How Do You Properly Fire an Employee in California?

California employers must follow strict legal guidelines when terminating employees to avoid wrongful termination claims and compliance issues. Proper documentation, adherence to state laws, and clear communication help mitigate risks and maintain workplace integrity.
How is overtime calculated in California

How Is Overtime Calculated in California?

California mandates overtime pay at 1.5 times the regular rate for work exceeding eight hours per day or forty per week. Employers must calculate overtime correctly, considering bonuses, multiple pay rates, and employee classifications under state labor laws.
What are common grounds for termination

What Are Common Grounds for Termination?

Termination decisions require careful consideration. This article outlines 25 legitimate reasons for dismissal, addressing ethical, legal, and performance-based concerns while emphasizing workplace integrity and compliance.
Can an employer require a doctor's note for just one day of work

Can an Employer Require a Doctor’s Note for Just One Day of Work?

An employer can request a doctor's note for a single sick day, but policies must comply with labor laws and employee privacy rights. Companies should clearly outline documentation requirements in handbooks, ensuring consistency while avoiding unnecessary medical inquiries.
When should an employer consult an attorney

When Should an Employer Consult an Attorney?

An employment attorney helps businesses comply with labor laws, draft contracts, and resolve workplace disputes. Employers should consult one when facing legal claims, employee conflicts, or compliance concerns.
What is the statute of limitations for PAGA claims

What Is the Statute of Limitations for PAGA Claims?

The statute of limitations for PAGA claims in California is one year from the most recent violation, with a 65-day review period tolling it. Recent reforms clarified that only employees personally affected by violations within the one-year period can file claims on behalf of others.
What is a short script for firing someone

What Is a Short Script for Firing Someone?

A structured termination script ensures a professional, clear, and legally compliant approach to employee dismissals. Proper preparation, direct communication, and empathy help minimize disruptions and potential legal risks.
What Constitutes Wrongful Termination in California

What Constitutes Wrongful Termination in California?

Wrongful termination in California occurs when an employer fires an employee in violation of state laws, contracts, or public policy. Employees may have legal options if dismissed due to discrimination, retaliation, contract breaches, or other unlawful reasons.
What Should Be Included in a Termination Letter in California

What Should Be Included in a Termination Letter in California?

A California termination letter should include the employee’s name, termination date, reason for dismissal, final pay details, and return of company property instructions. It should also mention any applicable severance, benefits continuation, and legal obligations like non-compete or confidentiality agreements.
What Are the Rules for Bereavement Leave in California

What Are the Rules for Bereavement Leave in California?

California law mandates that employers with five or more employees provide eligible workers with five days of bereavement leave. This leave must be used within three months of a family member's passing, with confidentiality and anti-discrimination protections in place.
What Is the Borello Test - Worker Classification and Legal Implications

What Is the Borello Test? Worker Classification and Legal Implications

The Borello test helps businesses in California determine worker classification by assessing multiple factors related to control and independence. Despite the ABC test's implementation, the Borello test remains relevant for specific exemptions and legal considerations in worker status disputes.
How Does an EEOC Complaint Hurt an Employer

How Does an EEOC Complaint Hurt an Employer?

An EEOC complaint can lead to legal costs, reputational damage, and increased scrutiny, even if an employer believes they followed regulations. Mishandling a complaint risks lawsuits, financial penalties, and long-term compliance challenges that impact business operations and workplace morale.
What Is the WARN Act in California

What Is the WARN Act in California?

California’s WARN Act requires employers to give 60 days’ notice before mass layoffs, relocations, or plant closures affecting 50 or more workers. Non-compliance results in penalties, including compensation for lost wages and benefits owed to affected employees.
What is self-employment tax and how is it calculated

What Is Self-Employment Tax and How Is It Calculated?

Self-employment tax covers Social Security and Medicare at 15.3% on net earnings exceeding $400, with deductions reducing taxable income. Payments are made quarterly, and half the tax is deductible, ensuring compliance with IRS regulations.
What Does Per Diem Mean in Employment Terms

What Does Per Diem Mean in Employment Terms?

Per diem employment offers flexibility with daily compensation for temporary or on-demand work, commonly found in healthcare, education, and business travel. Unlike independent contractors, per diem employees receive wages subject to taxes but often lack benefits like health insurance.
How Many Hours Are Considered Part-Time

How Many Hours Are Considered Part-Time?

Part-time jobs generally involve fewer than 35 hours per week, but definitions vary across industries and labor laws. Employers must track work hours to determine eligibility for benefits, overtime pay, and regulatory compliance.
What Does an Employment Litigation Attorney Handle

What Does an Employment Litigation Attorney Handle?

An employment litigation attorney handles workplace disputes, including wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, and retaliation claims. Legal representation ensures employees and employers navigate complex regulations, resolve conflicts, and protect their rights.
What Is the Medical Pre-Tax Deduction

What Is the Medical Pre-Tax Deduction?

A medical pre-tax deduction allows employees to pay health insurance premiums before taxes, reducing taxable income. Self-employed individuals may deduct premiums if not eligible for employer-sponsored coverage, with additional rules for health savings accounts and itemized medical expenses.

Contact our attorney.

Please tell us your story:

4 + 3 = ?